top of page

Newsletters

The New 2026 Top Colleges and Universities?

Nov 12
3 min read

Despite chatter about the purpose and relevance of higher education, parents still have high expectations that their children will go to a “top school.” But what is that designation based on? Status? Selectivity? Brand strength?


There is a new list that might change how we think about higher education. City Journal just released its 2026 College Rankings.

According to City Journal,

“College shapes a student’s mind and character—for better or for worse. It helps form the person you become. It educates—or miseducates. Yet rankings typically focus on factors that say little about how a school will influence your future. They tell you almost nothing about the content of the education, the campus environment, or the institution’s core values. With higher education in crisis, you need the most relevant information in order to choose the right college.”“Does a college encourage respectful discussion and vigorous debate? Is the curriculum strong, or is the university coasting on a reputation that it earned a century ago?
Does the school force divisive ideology on its students? Do administrators prioritize activism over education—and even tolerate chaos and violence? Are students taught how to think—or are they told what to think? Does the school prepare them to earn enough to pay back their tuition and thrive as citizens and workers in the twenty-first-century economy?”

See the full rankings list here:





Established lists like U.S. News & World Report and Forbes have long prioritized institutional prestige, selectivity, and alumni earnings, among other factors. The City Journal College Rankings differ from traditional ranking systems by placing greater weight on campus free speech, ideological diversity, and institutional governance, alongside traditional financial outcomes.





One takeaway from the 2026 City Journal College Rankings is that large public flagship universities outperform most traditional Ivy League and elite liberal arts colleges when evaluated on free speech, ideological pluralism, meritocracy, and resistance to politicization.



Do college rankings really matter?

There has been endless attention paid to the high-stakes world of college admissions, with parents trying to “game the system” for their children through influence, donations, athletics, tutoring, extracurricular activities, etc.


In The Parents Suing Schools Because Their Kids Got Bad Grades, Zusha Elinson writes that “In Silicon Valley and beyond, families are pressuring teachers or calling lawyers over classroom clashes, from a recess squabble to an essay flagged as ‘76% AI.”


He notes that parents worry that a single bad grade or unfair evaluation could permanently harm their child’s record and hurt their chances of getting into top universities like Stanford.


“40% of American teachers report facing pressure from moms and dads to change grades.”

But what if shielding children from every bad grade or critical comment prevents them from learning how to handle setbacks, adapt to tough feedback, and build independence and resilience before college or adulthood?


The path to success does not necessarily run through an elite university. As evidenced by the table below, public and state universities produce the vast majority of top-tier CEOs, and some of the most accomplished leaders never earned a college degree.


Top 25 Fortune 500 CEOs and Their Colleges (As of 11/12/2026)

*Table generated using Google Gemini (2026)
*Table generated using Google Gemini (2026)

As new frameworks like City Journal’s emerge, perhaps parents can step back and contemplate a different set of criteria for what truly matters in higher education as they consider where their children might thrive.



Thanks for reading Parents Unite! Subscribe to our Substack for free to receive new posts and support our work.



 
 

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page